[willo8]

re: Buddy v roughead they're very different players but i think you'd struggle to find a club that would take roughy over buddy.

Roughy has it over buddy in that he is a much better mark, a slightly more reliable kick and a handy ruck option.

For me their differences were highlighted when we played essendon, fletcher looked pretty good one on one against roughead and ryder was doing OK on buddy. They switched and both of the defenders looked second class.

but they're are hard to compare given they're so different.