| I went to the WA vs NSW/ACT game today at Subi (didn't watch the Freo vs. Port Adelaide though). My thoughts on the game (as posted at BF):
A fairly meek game from a viewing perspective, little to no contest and the skills weren’t as outstanding as I’d expected from WA, but nevertheless a comfortable 10+ goals win to WA.
WA 15.7 (97) defeated NSW/ACT 4.3 (27)
WA BEST: Walters, Naitanui, Bennell, Jetta, Hill, Lucas, Daly
NSW/ACT BEST: Ranga, Kirkwood
Walters – Very classy. Decision making and kicking was very good (set up a few goals early) and kicked a couple of goals himself. Safe hands as well - took a v.good OH grab too up forward. He’s small and slightly built, but more than willing to put his body on line when needed. 20 disposals, 3 goals.
Lucas – Played an outside role - ran the lines and generally used the footy well. 21 disposals.
Naitanui – When he got it there was an air of excitement and you knew something good was going to happen. His inside work, acceleration, tackling and second efforts are fantastic for a small mid let alone a ruckman. Abosultely dominated tapwork wise – I can’t remember the NSW/ACT bloke getting a clear tap. Didn't notice him getting a heap of the footy but when he did he had an impact - no junk possessions. 8 disposals, 20 hitouts (5 to advantage), 6 tackles, 1 clearance.
Hill – very nice burst of speed/turn of pace. Took a couple of nice grabs and can lay a fair tackle too. Played with very good intensity. Looking forward to seeing more of him play.
Rich – Was well held for most of the game by Kirkwood. Did the bulk of his work inside the pack freeing up others with handpasses, tackling etc., with only a couple of his scintillating, accurate left foot passes on display. Had very little impact in the first half, but improved in the 2nd, particularly the last ¼. Overall it was a disappointing game from him – I expected more from Rich. 15 disposals.
Jetta and Bennell – Jetta played mostly on the wing pushing forward. Bennell was more FP (kicked 4). Both were very good (amongst the BOG) and are clever/sneaky/pacy/elusive/skilful and can kick goals - the types of players lacking at WC.
De Boer – Loves to get the HB receive and back himself to run the lines. Unfortunately his kicking let him down on several occasions. Was fairly prominent in the 1st half, but dropped off in the 2nd. 24 disposals.
Daly – Played as a lead-up FF. Kicked a tidy amount of goals (5). Hard to judge accurately how good any of the big forwards were as WA had a ridiculous amount of forward entries.
From NSW/ACT, no real standouts apart from Ranga (Geelong NSW/ACT scholarship) who is **** good, was instigating everything for NSW/ACT with his inside work (but unfortunately for him wasn't surrounded by a lot of quality). Kirkwood (did the job on Rich - could he be the McGinnity of this year?) and McNeill seemed decent (nuggetty inside, Sydney-style type). Reed (Collingwood NSW/ACT scholarship) was alright, not sure who he was on, but he’s the modern day tall rebounding CHB/HBF prototype that seems to be very popular these days - runs and carries the footy off the defensive 50 and kicks long.
Out of the well known WA players, Swift and Yarran didn’t play. Also, Anthony Stubbs (WCE NSW/ACT scholarship) didn’t play. __________________
-- AUGUST 2007 -- Last edited by ravadongon : 06-03-2008 at 10:59 AM. Reason: Added some stats. |