Are two Cornes too many?

[LG3]

Hi all

After some mucking around, I've managed to get both Cornes in the one team without, I think, compromising much elsewhere. At the end of the DT season last year, I had both players and it was working pretty well!

I wanted to get your views on the value of this investment. While I'm obviously not expecting them to have huge increases in value, if they keep performing well with good scores and maitain their current value (and play the whole season) I think I'll come out of this well.

The other alternative is to look at trading Kane for someone like Nathan Foley (who performed well last year) and spend the $100k+ in savings on upgrading my forward line a bit (change Harding?).

I've listed my current team below for context. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you
LG

DEFENDERS
1. CORNES, Chad
2. BIRCHALL, Grant
3. JOHNSON, Michael
4. JOHNC0CK, Graham
5. MCPHARLIN, Luke
6. PETTERD, Ricky
7. ELLIS, Xavier
*23. SELWOOD, Scott (maybe switch to Myers from Ess)
*24. PFEIFFER, Darren

MIDFIELD
8. CORNES, Kane (switch for Foley?)
9. THOMPSON, Scott
10. SCHAMMER, Byron
11. STEVENS, Nick
12. HOULI, Bachar
13. MORTON, Cale
*25. PALMER, Rhys
*26. BIRD, Craig

RUCKS
14. MCINTOSH, Hamish
15. SIMMONDS, Troy
*27. KREUZER, Matthew
*28. TIPPETT, Joel

FORWARDS
16. PAVLICH, Matthew
17. RIEWOLDT, Nick
18. BROWN, Nathan G.
19. FRANKLIN, Lance
20. FEVOLA, Brendan (or Hall - still torn)
21. PORPLYZIA, Jason
*22. SELLAR, James
29. HARDING, Leigh
*30. RIOLI, Cyril

*Bench

[peterfitz]

2 Cornes is never too many.
1-2 Cornes is essential
0 Cornes is almost disaster!

If there were 5 Cornes brothers they'd all be considered for selection

[TooManyMelbourneTeams]

Both got 100+ tonight. I have both with Kane as capt.

[Borak]

In society, yes
in dream team, no

[ALI-G]

Originally Posted by TooManyMelbourneTeams

Both got 100+ tonight. I have both with Kane as capt.

I 2nd that motion. Went with the wrong one for Captain but can't really be dissapointed 100+ as captain will do me each week.

[EagleRock]

I also have Kane as captain but dont have Chad which im regretting a little bit.

[LG3]

In the end I went with the two Cornes combo and am happy with the results after Round 1!

Had Chad as Captain.