Is Sydney better without Hall?

[Don]

Given the result last weekend, and the controversy with Barry Hall, are Sydney better off without him ????

Im not picking on Barry I think he is a very talented player but if he puts in a bad one the Swans seem to starve for goals, without him they seem to find alternative avenues for goal.

With the finals coming should the Swans play him or not? what would you do?

I have a feeling that if Sydney dont play him in the finals he may retire a broken man.

Maybe CHB is an option ?

[Plugg3r]

I hope he just picks up his game a great deal..
He is a back bone when in top form for the swans, prior to his first suspension he was on top form.

I hope he can return to his great form and his previous restraint and help swans win in 08'

[OLDFELLA]

Talk about Royce Hart, Jezza, Hudson, Bartlett, Keogh or any of the memorable players at the pub, and everyone will remember how good they were.
Talk about Hall in the future, and he will be remembered for being a cheap shot thug and compared to Carey.
Sydney know they're better off without the big girl.

[ALI-G]

Regardless of his antics on-field this year Hall is still one of the top forwards in the game hence making Sydney better off with him. If he can find a way to pull his head in he will play a pivotal part in Sydneys finals campaign without him in full flight I don't think Sydney can challenge the top 3 teams.

[jas929406]

Love to see Big Bad Barry Back to his best but i think his days are gone in the AFL.

Fingers crossed.........**** him.

[OLDFELLA]

Originally Posted by ALI-G

Regardless of his antics on-field this year Hall is still one of the top forwards in the game hence making Sydney better off with him. If he can find a way to pull his head in he will play a pivotal part in Sydneys finals campaign without him in full flight I don't think Sydney can challenge the top 3 teams.

He's good because the opposition realize there is life after football.

They don't want to lose an eye to a gouge or be knocked senseless with a cheap shot king hit for trying to mark him.
Not having their kidneys strained through their ribcage by “BIG BAD BARRY’S” knee momentum is a good thing too I would suspect.
How many times has he been done for Knees in the back again?

Barry hall is not a footballer with a problem, He is a cheap shot gutless thug who plays a bit of footy.

[Stu]

How ironic that his replacement on the Sydney forward line is Henry "Playfair"...

[jas929406]

Originally Posted by Stu

How ironic that his replacement on the Sydney forward line is Henry "Playfair"...

Good call Stu