NoviceCoach needing help - Page 2 - AFL Footy Forum

Chaddy chaddy bang bang · #11 (**permalink**) 03-19-2008, 12:57 AM

Yep i really like the both of them. Personally i havent got them, but i have had them in my side 10 times whilst i have brrn tinkering.

Le cras will get a lot more opportunities maybe even on the ball at some stage, and roughhead is a champion in the making, and with hawthorn really turning it on this year and there good midfiels rhead could see alot of scoring opportunities...

You can check my team i posted a topic on here as well (feed back appreciated good supercoach team (i think?)) good luck

NoviceCoach · #12 (**permalink**) 03-19-2008, 10:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chaddy chaddy bang bang

Yep i really like the both of them. Personally i havent got them, but i have had them in my side 10 times whilst i have brrn tinkering.

Le cras will get a lot more opportunities maybe even on the ball at some stage, and roughhead is a champion in the making, and with hawthorn really turning it on this year and there good midfiels rhead could see alot of scoring opportunities...

You can check my team i posted a topic on here as well (feed back appreciated good supercoach team (i think?)) good luck

I got rid of LeCras, just don't know much about him. A Hawthorn member is making me have some second thoughts on Roughie. He said he's probably not going to get a lot of chances up forward this year.

NoviceCoach · #13 (**permalink**) 03-19-2008, 10:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NoviceCoach

I got rid of LeCras, just don't know much about him. A Hawthorn member is making me have some second thoughts on Roughie. He said he's probably not going to get a lot of chances up forward this year.

Succumbed to pressure, swapped Hahn for Roughead. Is this an improvement?

NoviceCoach · #14 (**permalink**) 03-31-2008, 11:09 AM

I want to make some value trades before the first price change.

Josh Drummond has been disappointing so far, and I read he's injured (I can't find a story that confirms this at this stage). Even if he's not, I'm thinking of doing a value downgrade.

Aaron Edwards has also not lived up to expectations. I'm thinking of maybe doing an upgrade using my proceeds from Drummond.

Chris Masten was pretty ordinary in his debut. Will he improve? Will he get to play more games? Or do I trade him now while I still can without losing a lot of money (Geary, Lonergan, Tuck, Morton)?

Help!

Chaddy chaddy bang bang · #15 (**permalink**) 03-31-2008, 10:18 PM

Hey mate read my post.. CHEAPIES BUT GOODIES.

That should help you out.

Get porplysia if you dont have him, young and a gun.

NoviceCoach · #16 (**permalink**) 04-01-2008, 07:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chaddy chaddy bang bang

Hey mate read my post.. CHEAPIES BUT GOODIES.

That should help you out.

Get porplysia if you dont have him, young and a gun.

Yes, I've certainly read your post. Very helpful.

I'm thinking Porplyzia for Edwards, Roughead for Drummond, then banking the extra cash for a future upgrade. What do you think?

Chaddy chaddy bang bang · #17 (**permalink**) 04-01-2008, 08:58 AM

Excellent, i know its only 2 games in and these guys have started like a house on fire. But they seem to be the big body boys who wont carry much injury and put up good numbers consistantly.

This will be a great move for your team mate. Plus you will save/make potentially 500,000. Go for it

NoviceCoach · #18 (**permalink**) 04-01-2008, 08:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NoviceCoach

Yes, I've certainly read your post. Very helpful.

I'm thinking Porplyzia for Edwards, Roughead for Drummond, then banking the extra cash for a future upgrade. What do you think?

I'm more or less settled on the Porplyzia for Edwards trade, but I'm still not quite sure about the Roughead for Drummond downgrade.

Is Roughead too much of a risk? Am I better off playing it safe with say, a Sam Fisher or a Heath Shaw for Drummond? Can you guys suggest anybody else?

Chaddy chaddy bang bang · #19 (**permalink**) 04-02-2008, 09:17 AM

Well i must say Heath Shaw is a scoring machine.

If you choose Roughhead or Shaw it wont really matter..

Shaw will smash him for points, but the $$$$$$$ you save will compensate for that easily.

Roughhead has taken the next step, Both are low risk, If your a gutsy type grab roughhead and power up someone later on.
If your the conservative type and not fully convinced then grab Shaw. Then you can live with yourself.
I think roughead end of season average will be approx 90 shaw approx 110

Either way its a Win Win situation for ya mate. Cheers

Johncock is good value!

NoviceCoach · #20 (**permalink**) 04-03-2008, 07:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chaddy chaddy bang bang

Well i must say Heath Shaw is a scoring machine.

If you choose Roughhead or Shaw it wont really matter..

Shaw will smash him for points, but the $$$$$$$ you save will compensate for that easily.

Roughhead has taken the next step, Both are low risk, If your a gutsy type grab roughhead and power up someone later on.
If your the conservative type and not fully convinced then grab Shaw. Then you can live with yourself.
I think roughead end of season average will be approx 90 shaw approx 110

Either way its a Win Win situation for ya mate. Cheers

Johncock is good value!

I grew some balls and went for Roughead. Keeping my fingers crossed.