My Supercoach Team Constructive Criticism Welcome

[tank33]

I am fairly happy with my team. I did have Lade in the ruck but changed him for Hudson and then picked up Chapman for Franklin and Birchall for Polak. What does anyone think of that move as I thought Lade was a little overpriced and might go down in value.

My team is

B Bowden J Cornes C Raines Birchall Kozi Hansen L Hunt S ( Ellis X Riggio)

C Judd Goodes Pearce Deledio Murphy Gibbs (Selwood THomas)

R Cox Hudson (Leuenberger Griffin)

F Hall Riewoldt Johnson B Chapman Pavlich Brown N (Rich) THomas D (Hawkins Edwards)

Theres only a couple of days to go so let me know what you think.

Have I chosen the right rookies ....
Hawkins and Edwards vs Davey and Jetta
Or is Kennedy J worth the extra $ over these??
Birchall or Raines?
Franklin or Brown or Thomas?

Thanks

[Clocktower]

Essentially nothing wrong with it. Riewoldt won't play 1st rd. You have a pretty envious forward line. You don't need ask b/w Franklin, Brown and Thomas...the answer is fairly obvious, just do some better research. Look back a couple of seasons and the answer is easy. There are no right rookies, purely as they are rookies, they are untested. Just look in papers, or internet 2morrow night and pick those who are playing.

[tank33]

Thanks Clocktower.

Im guessing that you are saying Nathan Brown is the superior player over Franklin and Thomas. Which I already knew but I had doubts over his recoery from his leg injuries.

Also what do u think if I traded Cox for Sandliands and then Pearce for Bruce??

[Clocktower]

I guess you've got to ask is Sandilands/Hudson/Bruce combo going to score as much as Cox/Sandilands/Pearce. The fact that hudson is in there, I don't think the sandilands hudson combo is as good. That said I am a dees man an Bruce will score his lazy 150 pts per game.

[tank33]

I agree that Bruce is a gun I had him last year and he was a weapon all year. I also had Pearce though and he had a great year and I think he will improve again this year. And he is a lot cheaper than Bruce and it allows me to have Cox.

Looking at my team though it wasnt a choice between Sandilands Cox Pearce compared to Sandilands Hudson and Bruce its...

Sandilands Hudson Bruce compared to Cox Hudson and Pearce

[Clocktower]

My only real concern with Hudson, is because he's so cheap, if injures himself early, you will be essentially a high scoring ruckman down. Yes Griffin will take his spot, but I doubt he'll grab the big points. I am still not convinced that Hudson will grab the big points, but his potential for price rise is too much to ignore.