Troy Simmonds or Leunberger?

[Ronnie]

Is troy simmonds capable of some of his fremantle and early richmond form?

[Tippaz]

i doubt he'll ever re-produce his stellar form of 2006
but his price is well below par and he should do a lot better than 2007

[Ronnie]

i cant quite fit him in right now, have gone for leunberger instead, what do you think?

[ALI-G]

I think it's much of a muchness. should get around 60's from both. Simmonds maybe 70's but probably less games.

[PAFC]

Simmonds easily. I'm yet to be convinced that Leuenberger can produce scores over 50.

[GreaT SourcE]

I'd go Simmonds quite easily on this one, but I think Simmonds will somehow cost you a trade throughout the season no doubt, whether it is due to injuries or poor form...He is quite tempting at his low price, but I'm going to resist him this year because he is a big IF imo....

[oaks]

did u c his game agaisnt carlton...20 hitouts,20 disposals

[PAFC]

Did you see his opponents?

[wcefan09]

Originally Posted by PAFC

Did you see his opponents?

hahah good call.

but im still inclined to go for simmonds over leuenberger. i think simmonds will definitely produce the higher scores. however berger did show a couple of good things during the west coast game and hopefully wont be too far off producing high scores. think he will struggle to get over 50 for a while to come though.

[grayza]

I got both and will Trade Leuenberger after half a dozen games for a bit of cash.