Trade proposal

[lenga89]

what do u guys think of barry hall. He had slow start with his injury but then dominated last round. Do u reckon he can keep this form up?

[aggie3]

as i said ablett befor but i didnt give a reason..
if ur goin for value i asure you ablett will be the best trade as he has stepped up another notch this year and his price will consistantly rise.. but if you dont need the $$ a agree with d swan that cornes is a good pick..

[aggie3]

duno about bazza,
ive got him, and the whole injury cloud is a little suss, i probs wouldnt buy him now just a bit risky.. though hes gone down a bit so if hes fit, thers a bit of value there

[D Swan MVP]

Originally Posted by lenga89

what do u guys think of barry hall. He had slow start with his injury but then dominated last round. Do u reckon he can keep this form up?

I have him and wasnt expecting him 2 play last week but did and played really well. I reckon he can keep this form but he has had this problem with consistency over the years so he will produce some bad performances

[zed327]

He's a champion and will show that again during the season.

[peterfitz]

Originally Posted by lenga89

Another trade I'm thinking of is:

Mcdougall for Hawkins

and then

R.Murphy for either C.Cornes or R.O'keefe or B.Hall or Fevola or Gary Ablett (can't decide which one)

Any feedback would be appreciated

Both great trades and I'd say both must be done.
I'd go for C.Cornes or Ablett from the choices. You obviously have Brown already? Or you're thinking of trading him into your team in 2 weeks?

[peterfitz]

Originally Posted by aggie3

what do u think about j bowden, trade him? and for whom

No. J.Bowden needs to stay.
I'll be surprised if he doesn't find form and even if he doesn't he wont score any less than he already is. You'd be better off waiting for another gun player to have a few bad weeks and i Bowden hasn't improved his scores by then you can make the trade.
Give him a chance. Chances are you'll be kicking yourself in the coming weeks if you trade him out.

[peterfitz]

Originally Posted by lenga89

what do u guys think of barry hall. He had slow start with his injury but then dominated last round. Do u reckon he can keep this form up?

Chances are he'll drop further at sometime during the season.
His price should drop a bit more this week after his low score in rd2. Look at him this week and consider him then or leave it 'til later in the season.

[D Swan MVP]

Jess Sinclair I am very disapointed with his start and am thinking of trading him for either McPhee or Shaw. Do you think I should trade him or have faith and give him a couple of weeks to perform.
your thoughts?

[peterfitz]

Originally Posted by D Swan MVP

Jess Sinclair I am very disapointed with his start and am thinking of trading him for either McPhee or Shaw. Do you think I should trade him or have faith and give him a couple of weeks to perform.
your thoughts?

I have Sinclair too and I'm keeping him. Although he has been disappointing he hasn't been TOO bad.
Besides, he started slowly last year too and then dominated late in the season.

McPhee and Shaw should both do very well this season though and will probably both outscore Sinclair over the season.

I guess you just have to weigh up whether it's worth "wasting" a trade from 1 good player to another. I don't think it's worth unless he's injured for atleast 2 weeks it but it's just my opinion.