Trade proposal

[lenga89]

With Andrew Browne (freo) out for a while with a hamstring injury i was thinking of making one of these trades

once trading Browne for Clinton Jones (St Kilda) who will be my second reserve:

1) J.Bowden to H. Shaw

or

2) Robert Murphy to Gary Ablett Jr (leaning towards this one)

[Age]

well this is quite a tough one. H.Shaw is a top player and definately worth his price tag IMO and J.Bowden i never expected to be in the top point getters to start with, although surely he'll pick up a few more points than he has been. Still, i doubt he will average the same as Shaw.

Robert Murphy is a good player but isnt at the stage of his game he was at before injury. not seeing as much of the ball and his vital mark count has dampened. He coul be the bigger hinderence for ur team. I like Gary Ablett as he is getting more of a run in the middle resulting in more possessions than last year, however a lot of them are handballs. His game will pick up another notch i believe and his kick and tackle count will grow.

If i had to choose one i'd go option 2 but only JUST. Murphy is a bigger problem than Bowden but Shaw is better than Ablett. Wat does everyone else think? Gd luck with ur choice.

[peterfitz]

Originally Posted by Age

well this is quite a tough one. H.Shaw is a top player and definately worth his price tag IMO and J.Bowden i never expected to be in the top point getters to start with, although surely he'll pick up a few more points than he has been. Still, i doubt he will average the same as Shaw.

Robert Murphy is a good player but isnt at the stage of his game he was at before injury. not seeing as much of the ball and his vital mark count has dampened. He coul be the bigger hinderence for ur team. I like Gary Ablett as he is getting more of a run in the middle resulting in more possessions than last year, however a lot of them are handballs. His game will pick up another notch i believe and his kick and tackle count will grow.

If i had to choose one i'd go option 2 but only JUST. Murphy is a bigger problem than Bowden but Shaw is better than Ablett. Wat does everyone else think? Gd luck with ur choice.

Agree. I would have had Ablett from the start but there were rumours of OP. Seems to be going well and should keep it up. Wish I'd gone with him!

[aggie3]

same question,
should i trade j bowden for an upcoming back (need ideas for that person)
therefore will save some $ for other up grades.

[lenga89]

Another trade I'm thinking of is:

Mcdougall for Hawkins

and then

R.Murphy for either C.Cornes or R.O'keefe or B.Hall or Fevola or Gary Ablett (can't decide which one)

Any feedback would be appreciated

[aggie3]

good trades,
get ablett i would think,
what do u think about j bowden, trade him? and for whom

[D Swan MVP]

Originally Posted by aggie3

good trades,
get ablett i would think,
what do u think about j bowden, trade him? and for whom

I think u should be patient and give bowden a couple of weeks, thats what im doing with him because I beleive he is going to come into form like previous years

[lenga89]

i know his form has been down so far, but i'm tempted to keep him for another week or so because of his point scoring history. If he doesn't perform i think i'll trade him as he will be becoming a liability to my team

[lenga89]

D Swam MVP which player do u think i should trade rob murphy for from the options i listed??

[D Swan MVP]

Originally Posted by lenga89

Another trade I'm thinking of is:

Mcdougall for Hawkins

and then

R.Murphy for either C.Cornes or R.O'keefe or B.Hall or Fevola or Gary Ablett (can't decide which one)

Any feedback would be appreciated

great trades I would get C. Cornes I have this feeling he will play a bit in the midfield in coming weeks (this very high scores)